Accounting Blog

When to Switch Accountants: Signs It's Time for a Change

Written by Przemek Cerazy | Jun 20, 2025 1:52:47 AM

As a principal at Cerazy Mitchler Corporation, I've had many conversations with business owners who are wrestling with a common question: "Is it time to switch accountants?" It's a big decision, and often, it's not made lightly. Your accountant is a vital partner, guiding your financial health and navigating the complexities of tax and compliance. However, just like any relationship, sometimes it's simply not working as well as it could be.

For businesses in construction, professional services, and manufacturing, having the right accounting partner can significantly impact your growth and profitability. So, how do you know when it's time to consider a change? Here are some clear signs that it might be time to seek out a new accounting relationship:

1. Lack of Proactive Advice & Strategic Planning

Are you only hearing from your accountant once a year at tax time? A truly valuable accounting partner does more than just process your numbers. They should be providing proactive advice on tax planning, identifying opportunities for efficiency, and helping you understand the financial implications of your business decisions throughout the year.

If your current accountant isn't offering insights on:

  • Minimizing your corporate tax burden
  • Optimizing cash flow (especially critical in construction and manufacturing)
  • Structuring your professional corporation for maximum benefit
  • ASPE updates affecting your industry
  • Future financial planning

...then you might be missing out on crucial strategic guidance.

2. Slow Response Times & Poor Communication

Do you send emails or leave voicemails that go unanswered for days, or even weeks? Do you struggle to get clear explanations for complex financial matters? Poor communication is a red flag. In business, time is money, and a responsive accountant is essential for timely decision-making and avoiding costly delays, especially when dealing with urgent tax matters or lending applications.

3. You Don't Understand Your Financials

Your accountant should be helping you understand your business's financial narrative, not just presenting you with a confusing set of numbers. If you constantly feel bewildered by your financial statements or struggle to get clear answers to your questions, it's a sign that the communication gap is too wide. A good accountant empowers you with financial literacy.

4. Missed Deadlines or Repeated Errors

While mistakes can happen, a pattern of missed deadlines for tax filings, financial statements, or other regulatory requirements is unacceptable. These can lead to penalties, interest charges, and unnecessary stress. Similarly, consistent errors in your books indicate a lack of diligence and attention to detail that can undermine your financial integrity.

5. They Don't Understand Your Industry

Accounting isn't one-size-fits-all. The nuances of job costing in construction, the unique revenue recognition challenges for manufacturers, or the specific compliance requirements for professional corporations require specialized knowledge. If your accountant doesn't grasp the intricacies of your industry, they might be missing critical opportunities or exposing you to unnecessary risks.

My experience in commercial lending, combined with our firm's focus on specific industries, means we speak your language.

6. Resistance to Technology and Modern Practices

Are they still relying heavily on paper, making you physically drop off documents? In an era where secure client portals, cloud accounting software, and digital communication are standard, a firm resistant to technology can hinder efficiency and security. A paperless, tech-forward firm like Cerazy Mitchler Corporation can offer significant advantages in terms of speed, accuracy, and accessibility.

7. You're Simply Not Feeling Valued

Ultimately, your relationship with your accountant should feel like a partnership. If you feel like just another number, or that your business isn't receiving the personalized attention it deserves, it might be time to find a firm that truly values your business and is invested in your success.

Making the Switch

Deciding to switch accountants can feel daunting, but the process doesn't have to be. A new firm will guide you through the transition, including obtaining your historical records and ensuring a smooth handover.

If any of these signs resonate with you, it's worth exploring your options. At Cerazy Mitchler Corporation, we're always open to a confidential, no-obligation conversation to discuss your current situation and explore how our specialized expertise can help your construction, professional, or manufacturing business thrive.